Size / / /

A story shouldn't be judged for its context, the time and place where it was written and/or published; a story should be judged for itself. And yet my fondness for "The Gods of Reorth" is born both of the story and of the cultural context in which it appeared.

This "introduction" contains major spoilers for the story, so read the story first if that will bother you.

Lizzy Lynn and I were close friends when this story was looking for a publisher, and we're close friends now, more than 30 years later. I read it first in manuscript, and it touched me deeply. Science fiction stories about women loving each other (outside of the lesbian small-publishing industry) were few and far between in the late 1970s. So, it was frustrating but not surprising when Liz got a rejection slip for the story on the ground that the main character's actions weren't adequately grounded in the story's action: in other words, finding the bloody murdered body of your lover is not enough motive for an act of revenge—as long as you and your lover are both women. Swap out Jael's gender for male, and no editor would ever have made that complaint.

Leaving the context behind, a few things jump out about the story: first, it is a science fiction story. Liz's language always has a fantasy flavor; even her hard SF novels often sound like epic fantasy. A good science fiction story should have a scientific backing that is essential to the story: Jael cannot be who she is, or do what she does, without the specific technology that backs her up. Her revenge is perfectly situated in her power, and her power is technological.

Second, it is a story of what happens when gods interact with humans. If any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic (Clarke's Law), then the wielders of any sufficiently advanced technology are indistinguishable from gods. And gods are lonely. What humans have to offer gods are intangibles, things the god cannot create for herself, such as companionship, trust, and ease.

And finally, the revenge at the end of the story is swift, implacable . . . and kind. This is not an "eye for an eye" or "life for a life" story; Jael could so easily do to the soldiers of Rys what they did to her lover; instead, she wreaks a vengeance that is powerful and bloodless, devastating and reparable. This is revenge as solution, not as endless loop.

If you like this story, find Liz's hard science fiction novels: A Different Light and The Sardonyx Net. Or her fantasy novels, the Chronicles of Tornor trilogy and the two newer ones (Dragon's Winter and Dragon's Treasure). Or even her most successful fantasy novella, "The Woman Who Loved the Moon" (in her collection The Woman Who Loved the Moon and Other Stories, which also contains this story)—that's the one she thought I should have picked for this showcase. You'll be glad you did.




Debbie Notkin has been a specialty bookseller, a reviewer for Locus, a fanzine publisher, an editor at Tor, a WisCon and FOGcon organizer, and more. She is the chair of the Tiptree Award motherboard. She blogs with Laurie Toby Edison, her photography partner in body image work, at Body Impolitic.
Current Issue
12 Jan 2026

Despite the barriers between different cetacean languages, our song crosses the vastness of the oceans, traveling in sync with the currents and even traversing great expanses of land. Our singing conveys the concept of “hope,” which is how we define the wait until our home feels safe again.
When you falter, recall that age is not your master
Do you swallow big blue whale eyes straight out of the jar?
When Le Guin talks about genre writers as “the realists of a larger reality” we surrender the power of that when we narrow our work to only depict one type of future. We have great power to restore alternate narratives, to re-broaden the range of imaginable futures.
Wednesday: We Will Rise Again edited by Karen Lord, Annalee Newitz, and Malka Older 
Friday: An Instruction in Shadow by Benedict Jacka 
Issue 5 Jan 2026
Strange Horizons
Issue 22 Dec 2025
Issue 15 Dec 2025
Strange Horizons
Issue 8 Dec 2025
Issue 1 Dec 2025
Issue 24 Nov 2025
Issue 17 Nov 2025
Issue 10 Nov 2025
By: B. Pladek
Podcast read by: Arden Fitzroy
Issue 3 Nov 2025
Issue 20 Oct 2025
By: miriam
Load More