This is always a fun time of year. As each issue comes out, we get some idea of what our readers are enjoying most, but even more than usual, 2012 was a busy year behind the scenes here, as we welcomed new fiction editors, poetry editors, and for the first time—thanks to last autumn's incredibly successful fund drive—a podcast editor. (Those of you who haven't yet subscribed to the podcast can find it in iTunes here, by the way.) So the Readers' Poll is a nice opportunity to look back at the whole of the last year in context.
In several categories, there is a clear continuity with last year. You can check out the full results for 2010 here and 2011 here, but the short version is: congratulations to Liz Bourke, Rose Lemberg and Genevieve Valentine for topping their respective categories for a second year running. (Indeed, Rose took the number one and number two spots in poetry this year.) We're always delighted to be able to publish their work. In the fiction category, meanwhile, congratulations to Rachel Acks, whose "Come the Huntsman" proved most popular. And in articles, our round-table on "Writing Climate Change" from last February was the winner—thanks again to Julie Bertagna, Tobias Buckell, Maggie Gee, Glenda Larke, Kim Stanley Robinson, Vandana Singh, and Joan Slonczewski for their time and contributions, which made the whole conversation so fascinating.
A quick recap of the rules. We asked you to vote for your favorite works from the fiction, poetry, and articles departments, and your favorite columnists and reviewers. The poll was open from 13.00 PST on 4th March 2013 until 23.59 PST on 11th March 2013. Each person could vote for up to five works or nominees, ranking them 1 (first place) to 5 (fifth place). Each first-place vote was worth five points, each second-place vote was worth four points, and so on. It was not compulsory to vote in every category, nor to use all five slots in a given category. Multiple votes on one ballot for the same item were discarded, and we required a unique email address for the ballot to be submitted. Those addresses were only used to verify the validity of ballots.
Finally, thank you to everybody who voted—and more of you did so than in either of the last two years, which is very gratifying. We'll do it all again this time next year.
- First place: "Comes the Huntsman" by Rachel Acks
- Second place: "Tiger Stripes" by Nghi Vo
- Third place: "Feed Me the Bones of Our Saints" by Alex Dally Macfarlane
- Fourth place: "The Grinnell Method" by Molly Gloss
- Fifth place: "Good Hunting" by Ken Liu
- First place: "Between the Mountain and the Moon" by Rose Lemberg
- Second place: "The Three Immigrations" by Rose Lemberg
- Third place: "Loki, Dynamicist" by Michele Bannister
- Fourth place: "Lost Letter" by Sofia Samatar
- Fifth place: "bell, book, candle" by Gwynne Garfinkle
- First place: "Writing Climate Change: A Round Table Discussion", featuring Julie Bertagna, Tobias Buckell, Maggie Gee, Glenda Larke, Kim Stanley Robinson, Vandana Singh, and Joan Slonczewski
- Second place: "Bridge Over Troubled Waters: The City of Haifa in Lavie Tidhar's stories", by Ehud Maimon
- Third place: "Cooking the Books: The Roundtable", by Fran Wilde
- Fourth place: "The Swedish Invasion: an interview with Karin Tidbeck", by Dustin Monk
- Fifth place: "Better Dead than Red: Politics and Genre", by Daniel M. Kimmel
- First place: Genevieve Valentine ("Intertitles")
- Second place: John Clute ("Scores")
- Third place (tie): Rochita Loenen-Ruiz ("Movements")
- Third place (tie): Eleanor Arnason ("Me and Science Fiction")
- Fifth place: Vandana Singh ("Diffractions")
- First place: Liz Bourke
- Second place: Lila Garrott-Wejksnora
- Third place: Benjamin Gabriel
- Fourth place: Sofia Samatar
- Fifth place: Niall Alexander